Sanibel and Captiva Islands Hotels

Overview

Just steps from shell-strewn beaches, many of the islands’ gracious hotels offer soothing views of the horizon, without a high-rise in sight (thanks to zoning laws that preserve the environment). Lovely accommodations present a range of choices, including beguiling cottages, quaint motels, contemporary more condo rentals, historic landmarks, and luxury resorts. Lavish comforts come “island-style,” with an emphasis on casual elegance. Comprehensive amenities include pools and spas, top-chef dining and superior bedding, and banquet halls for picture-perfect weddings. Larger groups can also opt to rent premium homes. In the moderate category, an array of hotels and cottage collections line Gulf Drive from east to west with ocean-facing balconies, poolside views, or garden patios. Equipped with standard amenities, these hotels typically pair wicker and rattan furnishings with pastel-colored, tropical accents. Many accommodations featuring kitchenettes offer weekly and monthly rates for long-term stays. There aren’t many budget-level lodgings on the islands, but anyone with a preference for cozy cottages or renovated, mid-century style motels, will have some money-saving options.

Sherman Meter Rating Beta

You get the best hotel advice with the Sherman Meter because we’re the only site that tabulates thousands of reviews from a variety of leading websites and factors in reviews from our own experts. The result is an overall hotel rating you can trust.

1  2  »  
Smart Splurge    Great Value
86%
Sherman Meter Rating
#1
Ranking

based on 38 reviews

4227 W. Gulf Dr.
Sanibel Island, FL
239-472-1600
Sherman's Expert Review
A cross between a B&B and an intimate motel, the family-owned Blue Dolphin offers nine airy...more
Tags: moderate | b&b | beachfront | editor pick
83%
Sherman Meter Rating
#2
Ranking

based on 70 reviews

3111 W. Gulf Dr.
Sanibel Island, FL
800-851-5088
Sherman's Expert Review
Established in 1895, this quaint resort facing 550 feet of beachfront has welcomed guests to...more
Tags: family | moderate | historic | great value | beachfront | editor pick
81%
Sherman Meter Rating
#3
Ranking

based on 138 reviews

2255 W. Gulf Dr.
Sanibel, FL
800-276-4753
Sherman's Expert Review
This exclusive resort was built in the old Florida spirit during the 1890s, but it’s still...more
Tags: luxury | spa | golf | smart splurge | expensive | editor pick
77%
Sherman Meter Rating
#4
Ranking

based on 386 reviews

5400 Plantation Rd.
Captiva, FL
866-565-5089
Sherman's Expert Review
A former key lime plantation, this resort’s old-world allure remains, with verandas and...more
Tags: luxury | smart splurge | expensive | tennis | editor pick
75%
Sherman Meter Rating
#5
Ranking

based on 25 reviews

1223 Buttonwood Lane
Sanibel, FL
239-472-4262
Sherman's Expert Review
Settle onto your personal porch at this charming property, conveniently located on a picturesque...more
Tags: romantic | moderate
75%
Sherman Meter Rating
#6
Ranking

based on 193 reviews

3345 W. Gulf Dr.
Sanibel, FL
800-824-0476
Sherman's Expert Review
On the quieter end of Sanibel, this Inn offers two types of accommodations: studio rooms with...more
Tags: family | moderate | beachfront
72%
Sherman Meter Rating
#7
Ranking

based on 98 reviews

863 E. Gulf Dr.
Sanibel, FL
866-565-5101
Sherman's Expert Review
Bathed in rosy tones, this intimate 30-room retreat is ideal for couples celebrating a...more
Tags: romantic | moderate | views
71%
Sherman Meter Rating
#8
Ranking

based on 284 reviews

17260 Harbour Pointe Dr.
Fort Myers, FL
800-767-7777
Sherman's Expert Review
For those seeking a high-rise experience, this complex is the place. Though not actually on...more
Tags: luxury | golf | family | expensive | tennis
71%
Sherman Meter Rating
#9
Ranking

based on 144 reviews

15951 Captiva Dr.
Captiva, FL
800-223-5865
Sherman's Expert Review
The renovated 1931 fishing cottages named after famous former guests like Charles Lindbergh and...more
Tags: family | moderate | great value | adventure
70%
Sherman Meter Rating
#10
Ranking

based on 34 reviews

367 Periwinkle Way
Sanibel, FL
888-345-0939
Sherman's Expert Review
In Old Town Sanibel near the lighthouse, this quaint inn offers efficiencies, deluxe studios,...more
Tags: moderate | garden | cottages
1  2  »  
Compare Rates
  • Flights
  • Hotels
  • Packages
  • Cruises
  • Cars
Enter your trip details
 
 
 
Enter your trip details
Step 1
 
 
 
Enter your trip details
Step 1
 
 
 
Enter your trip details
Step 1
 
 
 
Enter your trip details
Step 1
 
 
   
 
Compare Rates
  • Flights
  • Hotels
  • Packages
  • Cruises
  • Cars
Travelers:
Travelers:
 

Deals