iStock International
ShermansTravel experts know where to find the best meal in town at the best price. Our restaurant reviews sift through the mountains of menus to highlight neighborhood gastronomic institutions and up-and-coming foodie hotspots – not to mention where to go for affordable, dependable fare complemented by a charming atmosphere.

Top Restaurants in Islamorada

Island Grill

An Islamorada hot spot for waterfront dining, the Island Grill's award-winning menu is full of seafood specialties sprinkled with Southern-style fare, like Southern-style shrimp and grits, Maryland-style crab cakes, and seafood tacos. Live music entertains diners from Tuesday through Sunday.

85501 Overseas Hwy. at MM 85.5, FL, 305-664-8400,
Tags: moderate | seafood | great value


For a twist on the Key's phenomenal seafood, this restaurant offers "Florida-infused Asian cuisine." Expect sushi, Saki, and dumplings, and specialty dishes like pork with Thai red curry sauce, and teriyaki chicken with tempura asparagus. Prices may be a bit higher than most area restaurants, but the chef prepares them with meticulous attention to detail in an artsy dining environment.

81701 Old Hwy. at MM 82, FL, 305-664-5556,
Tags: expensive | sushi | asian

Keys Fisheries

Although it's a bit of a drive from Islamorada (about 45 minutes), this popular dining spot is worth the detour, not only for the tasty fare at the casual seafood eatery, but for its atmospheric setting amidst a fish market and marina. Restaurant tables are set on an outdoor patio on a dock over the water - don't be surprised to have large fish and pelicans cluster nearby. Self-service meal orders are made at a window, off a menu board mounted on the wall - order pickups are called out based on the theme of the day (via the name of your favorite movie, song, etc.). The menu consists almost entirely of fresh seafood, but their all-time specialty is the lobster Reuben sandwich.

3502 Gulf View Ave. at MM 49, FL, 305-743-4353,
Tags: budget | seafood | editor pick | great value


Cabana bars and live music set the tone for sunset entertainment at this waterfront restaurant, but in-the-know early risers head here for its impressive breakfast. There are few surprises on the menu, just good old-fashioned pancakes, omelets, French Toast, and Bloody Marys to wash it all down. Lunch and dinner items include sandwiches, burgers, and seafood dishes.

81924 Overseas Hwy. at MM 82, FL, 305-664-2692,
Tags: seafood | brunch


This colonial-style beachfront restaurant is perfect for a romantic evening, with a white-washed wraparound porch that provides an intimate outdoor setting and fantastic views. The menu consists of French cuisine with Asian and Floridian influence like Tempura Lobster tail and Miso seared sea scallops.

81600 Overseas Hwy. at MM 81.6, FL, 305-664-3225,
Tags: expensive | smart splurge | french fusion

Wahoos Bar and Grill

This classic Keys eatery is a great stop for enjoying lunch outside in the sunlight, with an oceanfront patio granting fantastic views of kite surfers and fishing boats returning to shore. The menu consists primarily of seafood dishes like crab legs, lobster, and oysters, but the real winner is the fish tacos.

83413 Overseas Hwy. at MM 83.5, FL, 305- 664-9888,
Tags: budget | seafood | american food

Compare Rates to Islamorada

Sign up for the Top 25 Newsletter
to get exclusive weekly deals

Tell Us Your Preferences

To help us understand your travel preferences, please select from the following categories

Check all that apply
Oops, something went wrong.
No Thanks