The Star Inn
It's no surprise that quintessential beach towns like New Jersey's Cape May shine brightest in summer: think wide sandy beaches, scenic boardwalks, and long afternoons by the water. And while hotels here often come with steep summer rates, The Star Inn offers a more accessible way to soak up the charm. Housed in a sunny yellow Victorian (with a retro motel tucked just behind it), this laid-back property offers breezy accommodations, amazing amenities, a central location just one block from the beach, and a hefty dose of nostalgia for good measure.
What You Need to Know
The Look of The Star Inn
Set just off the beach on a corner lot, The Star Inn blends in easily with the easygoing rhythm of Cape May, though its cheery yellow facade makes it hard to miss. The main building, a restored Victorian-era home, features mint-green trim and a wide front porch lined with rocking chairs for al fresco mingling. Behind it, a mid-century motel structure houses suites that echo the property's breezy, beachy character while adding practical perks like kitchenettes and outdoor seating areas.
Rooms are minimal with crisp white linens, simple furnishings (such as desks, dressers, and bed frames), and subtle coastal accents (including pops of blue, seashell prints, and driftwood-style mirrors). Select Inn rooms come with perks like ocean views or private backyard courtyards. The motel-style Star Suites include kitchenettes, sitting areas, and small outdoor spaces (either porches or patios). For larger groups or families, the two-bedroom Carriage House Suites offer full kitchens, in-unit washer/dryers, and ocean-facing decks.
The Vibes at The Star Inn
Think of The Star Inn as a cross between a boutique inn and a retro beach motel. Don't expect scene-y common areas, rooftop bars, or curated programming — just simple, comfortable rooms a block from the ocean and within walking distance of Cape May's main shopping and dining streets. Guests breeze in and out, picking up takeout, heading out with beach chairs in tow, or starting the morning with coffee and a pastry from the Cozy Café, tucked into a corner of the main house.
Who Will Love The Star Inn
The Star Inn is a good fit for couples, small families, and friend groups who want to be close to the beach and downtown without paying top-tier resort rates. Since some suites include kitchenettes or laundry access, they're especially practical for longer stays or travelers who prefer a bit more independence.
Best Amenity at The Star Inn