Martha's Vineyard

iStock International
ShermansTravel experts know how to pick a good hotel. Whether in the budget, moderate, or luxury price range, the hotels we recommend always meet our highly selective criteria for what amounts to an unbeatable experience. We look at location, comparing the hotel to other offerings in the area; price range, determining where the hotel falls on the scale of affordability, and whether it merits the expense; and finally, experience, that all-important benchmark covering everything from aesthetics to service. We assess every aspect of the hotel experience, from beds and views to service and that indefinable thing called vibe.

Top Hotels in Martha's Vineyard

Beach Plum Inn

Tucked away in picturesque Menemsha, the 12-room Beach Plum Inn is far from the Edgartown ... more

50 Beach Plum Ln.
Menemsha , MA
Tags: romance | moderate | views
Charlotte Inn

This 19th-century, English-style inn is unmatched on the island for comfort, style, and ... more

27 South Summer St.
Edgartown , MA
Tags: luxury | romance | expensive | editor pick | smart splurge | great location
Duck Inn

Duck Inn welcomes adults and kids alike into its 5-room, colorful, eccentric interior (the pink ... more

10 Duck Pond Way
Aquinnah , MA
Tags: family | budget
Harbor View

Guests are pampered in this stately, 114 room and suite, 19th-century property with turndown ... more

131 N Water St.
Martha's Vineyard , MA
Tags: luxury | family | expensive | great location | views
Mansion House

For top-tier service without the “top-tier” price tag, head to the Mansion House ... more

9 Main St.
Tisbury , MA
Tags: moderate | editor pick | great value
Nashua House Hotel

Quite possibly the most affordable accommodation on the Vineyard, cottage-style Nashua House is ... more

9 Healy Way
Oak Bluffs , MA
Tags: budget | editor pick | great location

Compare Rates to Martha's Vineyard

Sign up for the Top 25 Newsletter
to get exclusive weekly deals

Tell Us Your Preferences

To help us understand your travel preferences, please select from the following categories

Check all that apply
Oops, something went wrong.
No Thanks