New York

iStock International
ShermansTravel experts know how to pick a good hotel. Whether in the budget, moderate, or luxury price range, the hotels we recommend always meet our highly selective criteria for what amounts to an unbeatable experience. We look at location, comparing the hotel to other offerings in the area; price range, determining where the hotel falls on the scale of affordability, and whether it merits the expense; and finally, experience, that all-important benchmark covering everything from aesthetics to service. We assess every aspect of the hotel experience, from beds and views to service and that indefinable thing called vibe.

Top Hotels in New York

1708 House

Relive the 18th century in high style at this antique-filled, heart-of-Southampton B&B where ... more

126 Main St.
Southampton , NY
631-287-1708
Tags: luxury | b&b | historic | expensive
6 Columbus

Like its sister property, 60 Thompson, the self-referential 6 Columbus provides cushy beds to ... more

6 Columbus Circle
New York City , NY
877-626-5862; 212-204-3000
Tags: moderate | trendy | great value
60 LES

Another addition to the 60 LES portfolio of boutique properties, this designer outpost sparked a ... more

190 Allen St.
New York City , New York
877-460-8888; 212-460-5300
Tags: luxury | trendy | designer | boutique hotel | spa
70 Park

Situated a few blocks from New York City’s iconic public library and Grand Central ... more

70 Park Ave.
New York City , NY
212-973-2400
Tags: luxury | expensive | great location | newly renovated | spa | yoga
Ace Hotel

Much has been made of how the Ace Hotel New York has transformed a distinctlyunhip Manhattan ... more

20 W. 29th St.
New York City , New York
212-679-2222
Tags: moderate | trendy | great value | hotel bar | jim's pick | smart luxury winner
Aloft New York Brooklyn

New York’s hippest borough now has plenty of hotels to match its buzzyvibe, but until ... more

216 Duffield St.
Brooklyn , NY
718-256-3833
Tags: moderate | trendy
Andaz Fifth Avenue

The second Andaz hotel to debut in New York after the Andaz Wall Street, the Fifth Avenue ... more

485 5th Ave.
New York City , NY
877-875-5036; 212-601-1234
Tags: luxury | smart splurge | great location
Andaz Wall Street

David Rockwell incorporates very subtle hints of the banking business (theAndaz Wall Street is ... more

75 Wall St.
New York City , NY
877-875-5036; 212-590-1234
Tags: moderate | design | business
Baker House 1650

Consistent with the 1650-manor-house style, deeply plush rooms, many with fireplaces and ... more

181 Main Street
East Hampton , NY
631-324-4081
Tags: luxury | b&b | historic | expensive | swimming pool | spa
Belhurst Castle

Stay in one of 14 architecturally unique rooms in a castle that dates to the 1880s. Listed on ... more

4069 West Lake Rd
Geneva , NY
315-781-0201
Tags: romance | moderate | historic | spa
Bowery Hotel

With the opening of their Bowery Hotel in early 2007, Eric Goode and SeanMacPherson (of Maritime ... more

335 Bowery
New York City , NY
212-505-9100
Tags: luxury | trendy | expensive
Chelsea Lodge

This B&B-style, three-story brick town house on a pleasant street offEighth Avenue has 26 ... more

318 W. 20th St.
New York City , NY
800-373-1116; 212-243-4499
Tags: budget | great value | great location
Comfort Inn Midtown

For a no-frills budget property, this well-located, 79-room hotel has somedecent amenities, with ... more

129 W. 46th St.
New York City , NY
800-517-8364; 212-221-2600
Tags: budget | great location
Cosmopolitan Hotel

Hiding behind a nondescript awning in TriBeCa is a relatively inexpensiveManhattan find ... more

95 W. Broadway
New York City , NY
888-895-9400; 212-566-1900
Tags: moderate | historic
Distrikt Hotel

Opened February 2010, Distrikt Hotel goes for a boutique feel with a New Yorktheme. The city is ... more

342 W. 40th St.
New York City , NY
888-444-5610; 212-706-6100
Tags: moderate | design | trendy | views | great value
Driftwood on the Ocean

This hotel, with its 10 secluded acres, beach, tennis courts, and barbecues on the sand, buzzes ... more

2178 Montauk Hwy.
Montauk , NY
631-668-5744
Tags: family | moderate | swimming pool | beach | tennis
Duane Street Hotel

In January 2008, the Duane Street Hotel moved into TriBeCa, and with a nod tothe local ... more

130 Duane St.
New York , NY
212-964-4600
Tags: moderate | design | boutique hotel | great location
Ecce B&B

Perched atop a bluff overlooking the Delaware River Valley, this charming B&B features ... more

12 Silverfish Rd
Barryville , NY
845-557-8562
Tags: moderate | b&b | views
Element New York Times Square West

The eco-wise concept behind Element Hotels is another Starwood trailblazer andthis Midtown West ... more

311 W. 39th St.
New York City , NY
212-643-0770
Tags: moderate | views | extended stay
Emerson Resort & Spa

Situated on a former dairy farm within the 600-square-mile Catskill ForestPreserve, Emerson ... more

5340 Route 28
Mount Tremper , New York
877-688-2828; 845-688-2828
Tags: spa | moderate | expensive
Empire Hotel

This Upper West Side mainstay opened in the 1890s, so it’s not exactly new. But with a ... more

44 W. 63rd St.
New York City , NY
212-265-7400
Tags: luxury | trendy | landmark | swimming pool | rooftop lounge
Eventi

A recent addition to the Kimpton Collection (opened May 2010) Eventi boasts 292rooms and suites ... more

851 Avenue of the Americas
New York City , NY
866-996-8396; 212-564-4567
Tags: luxury | spa | art | expensive | eco-friendly
Four Corners Country Inn

Indulge in the fattening French fare at this romantic, corner-hill-perched B&B, which is ... more

1564 Wittenberg Rd.
Mt. Tremper , NY
845-688-3054
Tags: culinary | budget | b&b
Four Seasons New York

Rising 52 stories behind a sleek French limestone facade in Midtown Manhattan, around the corner ... more

57 E. 57th St.
New York City , NY
800-819-5053; 212-758-5700
Tags: luxury | smart splurge | expensive | smart luxury winner | family | art
Gansevoort Park Avenue

Like its sister property in the Meatpacking District, the latest Gansevoort(opened August 2010) ... more

420 Park Ave.
New York City , NY
212-317-2900; 877-830-9889
Tags: luxury | spa | trendy | expensive | swimming pool | rooftop lounge
Geneva on the Lake

The 29 suites and studios in this Italian Renaissance-style hotel, built as a private home in ... more

1001 Lochland Rd.
Geneva , NY
315-789-7190
Tags: luxury | romance | smart splurge | historic | expensive
Gild Hall

The Financial District's first boutique hotel, Gild Hall, like its sister properties in the ... more

15 Gold St.
New York City , NY
800-268-0700; 212-232-7700
Tags: luxury | design | boutique hotel
Golden Guernsey

Painted in swaths of bright marigold, this cute-as-it-sounds B&B is run bya young, artistic ... more

31 Mitchell Pond East
Cochecton, , NY
845-932-7994
Tags: moderate | b&b
Gramercy Park Hotel

Boutique hotel kingpin Ian Schrager is the mastermind behind the 185-roomGramercy Park Hotel, ... more

2 Lexington Ave.
New York City , NY
866-784-1300; 212-920-3300
Tags: luxury | design | trendy | expensive
Greenwich Hotel

Robert De Niro launched his 88-room destination in his beloved TriBeCa in April 2008 with little ... more

377 Greenwich St.
New York City , NY
212-941-8900
Tags: luxury | spa | expensive | swimming pool | editor pick
Gurney's Inn Resort

Situated on a windswept bluff overlooking an expansive ocean beach, this self-contained resort ... more

290 Old Montauk Hwy.
Montauk , NY
631-668-2345
Tags: luxury | girlfriend getaway | expensive | spa
Herald Square Hotel

Golden cherubim welcome guests to this historic property (dating from 1883),which heralds the ... more

19 W. 31st St.
New York City , NY
800-727-1888; 212-279-4017
Tags: historic | great value | great location
High Peaks Resort

This Main Street stunner was completely reborn in summer 2008, with a multi-million dollar ... more

2384 Saranac Ave.
Lake Placid , NY
800-755-5598
Tags: moderate | great value | spa | swimming pool
Hillcrest Manor

Built in 1890, this neoclassical, five-room manor—with links to Corning’s glass ... more

227 Cedar St.
Corning , NY
607-936-4548
Tags: moderate | boutique hotel | b&b
Hilton New York Fashion District

From its rooftop lounge and the free Crumbs cupcake at check-in to the list of weekly sample ... more

152 W. 26th St.
New York City , NY
212-858-5888
Tags: luxury | trendy | expensive | rooftop lounge
Hotel Grace

Popular with New Yorkers looking to make a splash at one of the city’s only indoor pool ... more

125 W. 45th St.
New York City , NY
212-354-2323
Tags: moderate | boutique hotel | swimming pool
Hotel Le Bleu

Opened in 2007, this eight-story stainless steel and glass tower rises tenselyover an ... more

370 4th Ave.
Brooklyn , NY
718-625-1500
Tags: luxury | trendy | expensive | boutique hotel
Hotel Le Jolie

Though just one subway stop from Manhattan on the L train and a 10-minute walkfrom Bedford ... more

235 Meeker Ave.
Brooklyn , NY
718-625-2100
Tags: moderate | boutique hotel
Hotel Marcel

This well-located, 135-room boutique hotel offers luxury amenities and a trendyatmosphere at a ... more

201 E. 24th St
New York City , NY
800-555-7555; 212-696-3800
Tags: moderate | trendy | great value | editor pick
Hotel Metro

Originally opened in 1901 and set just a block from the Empire State Building and Macy’s, ... more

45 W. 35 St.
New York City , NY
800-356-3870; 212-947-2500
Tags: moderate | historic | gardens
Hyatt 48 Lex

In an area where most hotels offer a soulless in-and-out experience forbusiness folk, Hyatt 48 ... more

517 Lexington Ave.
New York City , NY
212-838-1234
Tags: luxury | new | business | expensive
Ink 48

Making an indelible mark as Hell's Kitchen first downright upscale property, Ink48 by Kimpton ... more

653 11th Ave.
New York City , NY
212-757-0088
Tags: luxury | spa | expensive | boutique hotel | biking | rooftop lounge | yoga
InterContinental New York Times Square

Opened July 2010, this 36-story, 607-room hotel is one of the largest built inNew York in the ... more

300 W. 44th St.
New York City , NY
888-424-6835; 212-803-4500
Tags: luxury | views | expensive | eco-friendly | notable chef
Kaatskill Mountain Club

If your intention is to roll out of bed and onto the slopes, you can't get any closer to the ... more

7740 Main Street
Hunter , NY
800-486-8376
Tags: luxury | spa | skiing | expensive | swimming pool
Kate's Lazy Meadow

Turn up the jets on the 20-person, salt Jacuzzi (complete with underwater light show) at B-52s ... more

5191 Rt. 28
Mt. Tremper , NY
845-688-7200
Tags: family | moderate | trendy | motel
La Tourelle Resort and Spa

This romantic getaway with 54 guest rooms in the French country style offers personalized spa ... more

1150 Danby Rd.
Ithaca , NY
607-273-2734
Tags: luxury | romance | historic | expensive
Larchmont Hotel

Located on a leafy Village side street, the Larchmont occupies a quaintbrownstone literally feet ... more

27 W. 11th St.
New York City , NY
212-989-9333
Tags: budget | great location
Library Hotel

You'll want nothing more than to curl up with a book at this cozy yetcontemporary boutique, ... more

299 Madison Ave.
New York City , New York
877-793-7323; 212-983-4500
Tags: moderate | unusual | great value | boutique hotel | great location | jim's pick
Mandarin Oriental New York

With floor-to-ceiling windows in every guestroom that overlook Central Park tothe east or the ... more

80 Columbus Circle
New York City , NY
866-801-8880; 212-805-8800
Tags: luxury | spa | business | expensive | celebrity hangout | swimming pool | jim's pick
Mansfield Hotel

Designed by architect James Remnick (St. Patrick's Cathedral) in high BeauxArts style and first ... more

12 W. 44th St.
New York City , NY
800-255-5167; 212-277-8700
Tags: moderate | landmark | great value | jim's pick
Mirror Lake Inn Resort & Spa

This lavish Lake Placid resort has been luring visitors to the Adirondacks since 1926. Upscale, ... more

77 Mirror Lake Dr.
Lake Placid , NY
518-523-2544
Tags: luxury | skiing | smart splurge | expensive | water sports | lake | girlfriend getaway
Mohonk Mountain House

This old majestic inn, built in 1869, overlooks sparkling Lake Mohonk in New Paltz, just 90 ... more

1000 Mountain Rest Rd.
New Paltz , NY
855-883-3798
Tags: luxury | smart splurge | historic | expensive
NU Hotel

No longer is Manhattan the only place where movers and shakers bed down in New York. Haven't you ... more

85 Smith St.
Brooklyn , NY
718-852-8585
Tags: moderate | trendy | designer | boutique hotel | biking
Roosevelt Hotel

This nearly 90-year-old Midtown landmark debuted rooftop bar, Mad 46, in summer2008. The slender ... more

45 E.45th St.
New York City , NY
888-833-3969; 212-661-9600
Tags: moderate | landmark
Roxbury Inn

This charming inn has been meticulously restored to its former mid-century, colonial glory. ... more

2258 County Hwy. 41
2258 County Hwy. 41
Roxbury , NY
607-326-7200
Tags: moderate | trendy
Soho Grand

This stylish, brick property touts 363 units decorated in cool, cerebral shapesand neutral earth ... more

310 W. Broadway
New York City , NY
800-965-3000; 212-965-3000
Tags: luxury | smart splurge | trendy | expensive
The Bridge Inn

The Hamptons’ only “chain” includes five motels in Bridgehampton, Wainscott, ... more

2668 Montauk Hwy
Bridgehampton , NY
631-537-2900
Tags: moderate | motel
The Chatwal

Formerly the home of the Lambs Club theatrical society, the 83-room Chatwal(opened August 2010) ... more

130 W. 44th St.
New York City , NY
800-524-2792; 212-764-6200
Tags: luxury | spa | historic | expensive | swimming pool
The Greenporter

The Greenporter offers cool, motel-style lodgings in the heart of Greenport’s quaint ... more

326 Front St.
Greenport , New York
631-477-0066
Tags: moderate | notable wine list | great location | hotel restaurant | swimming pool
The Inn at Glenora Wine Cellars

Guests checking into this spacious, comfortable, full-service hotel adjacent to the winery ... more

5435 Route 14, Dundee
Finger Lakes , NY
800-243-5513
Tags: moderate | views | great value | winery
The James New York

With a prime SoHo address, the James (opened September 2010) promises a bound-to-be-a-hot-spot ... more

27 Grand St.
New York City , NY
212-465-2000; 888-526-3778
Tags: luxury | expensive | swimming pool | rooftop lounge | family
The Jane

Built in 1908 as a refuge for sea-weary sailors, the restored Jane Hotel, a red-brick ... more

113 Jane St.
New York City , NY
212-924-6700
Tags: moderate | trendy | cafe | biking
The London NYC Hotel

Subdued without being overly minimalist (per famed design firm David CollinsStudio) and ... more

151 W. 54th St.
New York City , NY
866-690-2029; 212-468-8856
Tags: luxury | smart splurge | expensive | jim's pick | smart luxury winner
The MAve

The New York-meets-Miami vibe of this moderately-priced boutique (opened in July 2009) is ... more

62 Madison Ave.
New York City , NY
877-959-3239
Tags: moderate | trendy
The Pearl of Seneca Lake B&B

This B&B’s rooms (named Chardonnay, Riesling, Merlot, and the Southview suite) all ... more

4827 Red Cedar Ln.
Dundee , NY
866-507-3275
Tags: budget | b&b
The Pod Hotel New York

The chintzy former Pickwick Arms has been painted over and transformed into a choice stay for ... more

230 E 51st St
New York City , NY
800-742-5945; 212-355-0300
Tags: budget | trendy | cafe | bar
The Roxbury

The Roxbury, a contemporary, design-oriented retreat, in a region overflowing with ... more

2258 County Hwy. 41
Roxbury , NY
607-326-7200
Tags: skiing | moderate | design | trendy | great value | spa | cocktails
The Standard

New York already has a dazzling bevy of hotels and big, exciting openings ofall sorts happen ... more

848 Washington St.
New York City , NY
877-550-4646; 212-645-4646
Tags: moderate | smart splurge | trendy | smart luxury winner
The Standard East Village

The Standard East Village, a 21-story white glass and aluminum tower that swells above the East ... more

25 Cooper Square
New York City , NY
888-251-7979; 212-475-5700
Tags: luxury | design | expensive | boutique hotel
The Surrey

A $60 million renovation in 2009 remade The Surrey from top to bottom. The hotel emphasizes ... more

20 E. 76th St.
New York City , NY
888-419-0052 or 1-212-905-1477
Tags: luxury | spa | trendy | expensive | hotel bar | hotel restaurant
The Whiteface Lodge

The Whiteface Lodge is hard to beat for families. The all-suite timber-and-stone beauty has got ... more

7 Whiteface Inn Lane
Lake Placid , NY
888-582-0505
Tags: luxury | smart splurge | all-suite | editor pick | swimming pool | tennis | spa | theater | waterfront
Trump SoHo

The Donald moved downtown in April 2010, with the arrival of the Trump SoHo Hotel. The ... more

246 Spring St.
New York City , NY
877-828-7080; 212-842-5500
Tags: luxury | spa | expensive | swimming pool | family | eco-friendly
W New York Downtown

See firsthand the “new downtown” in the making: The W is amongseveral recent ... more

123 Washington St.
New York City , NY
888-625-4988; 646-826-8600
Tags: luxury | views | bar menu | hotel bar | hotel restaurant
Waldorf-Astoria

Covering a full city block, this East Midtown dame swept onto the New Yorkscene in 1931 and has ... more

301 Park Ave.
New York City , NY
800-924-3673; 212-355-3000
Tags: luxury | spa | historic | expensive
Washington Square Hotel

Yes, Bob Dylan and Joan Baez once lived here, and its 150 smallish rooms are comfortable, but ... more

103 Waverly Place
New York City , NY
800-222-0418; 212-777-9515
Tags: moderate | great value | great location | lounge

Compare Rates to New York






Karen_dion

“On an open-seating flight, head for the back of the airplane. If the flight's not full, it'll likely be emptier back there.”

Karen Dion Freelance Editor

Sign up for the Top 25 Newsletter
to get exclusive weekly deals